The Alberta Federation of Labour (AFL) has expressed that the provincial government’s choice to invoke the Charter’s notwithstanding clause to compel striking teachers to return to work is a perilous moment for democracy and labor rights.
Gil McGowan, the AFL president, informed the media on Monday that Premier Danielle Smith’s administration “had alternatives” but opted for what he described as the “nuclear” option.
“They chose confrontation and escalation rather than compromise and negotiation,” McGowan stated.
“In doing so, they have shifted this conflict from a disagreement between teachers and the government to a clash between the government and the wider labor movement.”
“We indicated that if this government was going to take the unprecedented step of revoking teachers’ constitutionally-protected right to strike and engage in collective bargaining, we would have no option but to respond with an unprecedented reaction.”
- Alberta teachers ordered back to work through expedited legislation, notwithstanding clause
- What you need to know as Alberta activates the notwithstanding clause
In the early hours of Tuesday, the Alberta government enacted Bill 2 — the Back to School Act — mandating a resolution.
The Alberta Teachers’ Association announced that classes would recommence on Wednesday but indicated it would “explore all legal options” regarding the legislation.
This bill utilized the notwithstanding clause to protect it from judicial scrutiny. It also imposes penalties of up to $500 daily on individuals and $500,000 on the Alberta Teachers’ Association if they disobey the back-to-work mandate.
Alberta Teachers’ Association president Jason Schilling expressed strong feelings about the presence of officials during the passage of legislation that compels teachers back into the classroom, noting that he witnessed emotional reactions from teachers in attendance.
Teachers have been on strike since October 6.
McGowan stated that the AFL, a coalition of 24 unions in both public and private sectors representing 175,000 workers, has allied with other unions as part of the Common Front coalition. Together, they represent nearly 400,000 workers, McGowan confirmed.
Emergency meetings were held by all unions in the province on Friday and Monday to tentatively establish a strategy in case the province opted to employ the notwithstanding clause, he said. This strategy was expected to be finalized during the lunch hour on Tuesday, he noted.
“Let there be no doubt, this is a moment where not only labor rights are at stake in this nation but also the very essence of our democracy,” he remarked.
“As the labor movement in this province, our leaders have pledged to meet that challenge, protect the teachers and their rights, advocate for broader worker rights, and defend our democracy. We have no alternative.”
While he refrained from confirming whether their response would involve a provincewide strike, he did mention, “it’s one of the options that is actively being considered.”
‘Undeniable moral obligation’
Education Minister Demetrios Nicolaides defended the legislation during discussions, stating that his primary goal was to return students to classrooms as swiftly as possible.
“The decisions being made this evening are not taken lightly,” Nicolaides told the assembly.
“I genuinely believe that the decision we are making tonight is fundamentally rooted in the undeniable moral obligation to prioritize the welfare and future of every student in this province.”
Finance Minister Nate Horner stated on Monday that invoking the notwithstanding clause would guarantee that when classrooms reopen, “they remain open.”


