A judge in Manitoba has expressed apprehension that the ongoing conversations about bail reform are undermining the presumption of innocence within Canada’s legal framework — a move that, according to a legal expert, could enhance public comprehension of the topic.
Provincial court Judge Dale Harvey remarked that while the presumption of innocence has consistently been a core tenet of Canadian law, “there appears to be a notable push lately, endorsed by some leaders, or self-styled leaders, within our institutions, to curtail that presumption through calls for substantial bail reform.”
Harvey stated, “The entire commotion surrounding the current state of bail and its application is, in my opinion, disrespectful to any member of the sitting court at any level in the present day — and stems from, at best, a misunderstanding of the relevant laws, or at worst, an ignorance of them,” during a recent bail hearing in Winnipeg, where he denied bail for an individual accused of drug trafficking while in custody.
His remarks coincided with the federal Liberal government’s proposals to amend the justice system aimed at keeping certain accused individuals incarcerated for extended periods as Ottawa attempts to reduce crime rates.
These proposals are intended to make obtaining bail more challenging, particularly for repeat and violent offenders. They include the introduction of “reverse onus” for specific offenses, meaning that detention becomes the default option and it falls upon the individual seeking bail to prove why they should not remain in custody while awaiting trial.
If these changes are approved by Parliament, the new reverse onus provisions will apply to those charged with violent or organized crime-related vehicle theft, breaking and entering, trafficking in persons, human smuggling, violent extortion, assault, and sexual assault involving choking, strangulation, or suffocation.
- Legal Aid Manitoba’s leader expresses concerns that proposed bail reforms could render the court system ‘much less flexible’
- Conservative MPs discuss bail reform at a town hall in Winnipeg
Judge Harvey’s recent statements also touched on the tertiary grounds for detention, which pertains to refusing bail to uphold public confidence in the justice system.
“That pertains to a reasonable member of the public,” Harvey explained. “Not someone who jumps to quick conclusions based on limited information, who is quick to write to the editor lamenting that the justice system is failing, without realizing that they themselves are a part of that system.”
Comments ‘bold’ but not concerning: legal expert
This hearing was not the first instance of Harvey addressing bail reform from the bench.
In a separate hearing last month, he noted that although the Criminal Code was changed in the past to incorporate the principle of restraint, potentially allowing more individuals a chance at bail, “there is now clearly a rising concern that too many individuals are being released from custody before trial, a reversal of the previous situation.”
In another bail hearing last month, Harvey reminded the court that “judges are not able to predict the future.”
“We cannot foresee what actions someone might take in the future. There have been numerous unfortunate incidents. However, not everyone can be denied bail — otherwise, we forsake the presumption of innocence and the Charter rights that everyone possesses,” he stated.
- Kinew’s comments on bail decisions undermine public trust in the justice system: Manitoba Bar Association
- Bail reform is a complex issue, according to Manitoba’s chief judge, amid increasing calls for change
“And for those who critique the justice system as being flawed or insufficient … I hope they do so with a clear understanding — yet often we observe individuals who lack knowledge of the law, who only focus on outcomes, and are nonetheless eager to share their uninformed opinions.”
A legal expert remarked that, while rare, he finds no fault in a judge making statements like Harvey’s — in fact, such remarks can contribute to a more informed public discourse on bail reform, according to Brandon Trask, an associate professor at the University of Manitoba’s law faculty.
“Just because it was daring doesn’t imply it was inappropriate,” Trask noted, adding that he believes some politicians have “misrepresented” the conversation surrounding bail.
“Judges are somewhat limited in what they can express outside the courtroom,” he explained.
“Observing a judge seizing the opportunity … to educate the public on what the system currently entails is, in fact, beneficial — and I would argue, rather refreshing in the context of a case like this.”
